Hey Eddie, I have this car, and I was lucky to get a red one from Exoticar for only $25 :danbana . I don't like dealing with them, (their customer service stinks), but for this price, I couldn't loose. Anyhow, I picked up a silver one off ebay about a year ago for in the mid $40 range. in my opinion, $59 is a little high. Offer him $45 or like the others said, 20%. This is more in line with what they are worth. Good luck :cheers